Copycat Panera® Broccoli Cheddar Soup Recipe

Rating: 3 stars
01/10/2014

This has the potential to be a really great broccoli cheese soup. As is, it’s just o.k. To me it tasted like broccoli with cheese sauce. It was bland and seemed to be lacking something. I’m thinking it’s the cooking process. It seems backwards. Typically, milk products are added last because simmering can cause curdling, especially if simmered for a long period of time. It works out o.k. for this recipe because it’s so thick from the cheese that you don’t really notice. What I found odd was that half of the cooking time is dedicated to just simmering the milk with plain stock, absent of any vegetables or seasonings of any kind. It’s only in the latter stage when you add the vegetables and those are only cooked just long enough until tender. Onions, celery, and carrots are essential when it comes to adding flavor to any soup broth and it takes time to develop that flavor. I would suggest adding those 3 ingredients to the chicken broth at the beginning so they have more cook time. The other change I would make is when to add the milk. I would start by adding the broth to the flour first and then the milk, but that’s just me.

Helpful

(1092)
Rating: 3 stars
11/25/2014

Three stars because it actually tasted good, but the whole cooking process was just strange. In all my years of cooking, I have never seen instructions like that. All you really gotta do is brown your butter, add the other veggies along with the broth, simmer til the vegetables are done. Then add your thickener - in this case, flour and melted butter. Then you add the milk and the cheese. It turned out great this way, and only took me and my daughter about a half hour to make it. Simmering the already thickened broth/milk for 20 minutes? Then adding the vegetables and cooking them for another 20 minutes? Seems to me that the recipe instructions are actually written in reverse!

Helpful

(871)
Rating: 5 stars
12/28/2013

I made this soup and my husband (who is not a really big soup fan) could not get enough of it. Only difference I made to the recipe was using 1 cup milk and 1 cup cream (since I had it on hand), rather than 2 cups 2%. Also, I didn't have the full amount of cheddar, so I threw in maybe 1/3 cup slab of veleeta to make up the difference. But I almost never have velveeta, and would recommend sticking with the cheddar just out of principle's sake. I used the stock to make the flour thickener rather than the milk/cream (just a preference). Then I added the milk and cream at the end with the cheese. It was definitely a delicious and thick soup, just like Panera's. Yum! Thanks a bunch, gildawen!

Helpful

(268)
Rating: 2 stars
12/09/2014

I hate to leave a 2-star, unfavorable review. However, to be fair to those who want to try this in the future, I want to give my opinion: it was bland and utterly tasteless. I was so disappointed that I didn't care how close it was to Panera's recipe -- I just wanted flavor! I ended up adding a tablespoon of garlic powder and 2 tablespoons of powdered chicken broth base (2 chicken bouillon cubes would work too), and this did the trick! We ended up with a very tasty soup for dinner, and I will make this regularly throughout the winter, WITH my additions. Good luck!

Helpful

(140)
Rating: 5 stars
01/21/2014

The family loved this soup. The only changes I made was to thin the roux with chicken broth instead of milk and added the broth instead of milk. Then I added all the veggies and simmered it, then added the milk at the end. Wonderful soup!

Helpful

(117)
Rating: 5 stars
09/14/2014

I've made this soup before using a different recipe, couldn't find the old recipe so I decided to give this a try. I used the exact measurements and ingredients listed except celery, the only other difference I made was instead of simmering the milk/flour/butter to thicken I used chicken broth as the liquid, let it simmer a little (around 7 minutes) added all my veggies and 1/2 cup of water (my burners are too strong and I feared all the liquid evaporating and becoming a pudding instead of a soup) and let it simmer until veggies were tender. Last step I added milk, cheese and served. WOW. BIG HIT with me and my husband who doesn't like soup. The flavor was all there, just be careful with adding salt as most chicken stocks already have sodium and cheese adds a lot.

Helpful

(69)
Rating: 3 stars
10/01/2016

*arthur fist* Like many of the other reviewers, I had to tweak the recipe. The instructions didn’t read well to me so I took some suggestions and now I think I have a good system to get things the way I’d like. I used 1.5 cups of sharp cheddar, 4 cups of chicken broth, 1 cup of heavy cream, 1 cup of thin carrots, 4 table spoons of butter, ¼ cup of flour, 2 cloves minced garlic, ½ onion, salt, pepper, garlic powder, 1 tsp of nutmeg 10 oz of broccoli. Steam broccoli until soft and easy to cut (It took forever to get soft simmering with everything else) In another pot sautee onions, carrots (if you don’t have a blender I’d make the pieces even smaller) in butter until tender, then add flour and cook for a minute. Add 2 cups of broth to onions, carrots, and flour mixture. Add in your cup of heavy cream and bring to a boil then lower the temp, remove from heat and add cheese gradually while stirring (if you throw in all the cheese at once it'll get clumpy). Your mixture should be thick at this point, add the last 2 cups of broth to thin it out, and add in your broccoli. Add seasonings to taste. Let simmer for awhile and it should be good to go.

Helpful

(43)
Rating: 4 stars
11/13/2014

As the submitter said it's open to what you like to make your changes to fit your taste. I found two copycat Panera bread broccoli-cheese soup recipes - here & food.com. They are very very very similar. Food.com adds nutmeg. I like the almost invisible taste of nutmeg in creamy soups. I am not a nutmeg fan (always halve it in baked goods) but in this soup: Mmmm! I changed the directions because they seemed really odd/off the order of things. This one says 1 1/2c broccoli; the other 1/2#. 'Pretty sure the answer is in between those two. I went with close to 1/2#. Daughter said it had too much broccoli or not enough cheese - didn't know which.:) Anywayyyy I microsteamed it three minutes then allowed to cool. I sauteed 2 medium sized cut-bigger-than-matchstick carrots in 1/4c butter 5 minutes; then added 1 pc celery diced sauteed 2 minutes; then about half cup onion (half onion) five minutes. 'Meant to do the sprinkling of 1/4c flour next but got ancy & added 2c homemade chicken broth next. Put that in a blender (daughter request) along with the broccoli then back in the pot & thickened once it got hot. After thickening added 1/4t salt & nutmeg; & 1/8t black pepper; 1c 2% milk; 1c half&half.(Probably go for all half&half next time or more thickener with milk). I chopped up an 8oz block Kraft sharp cheddar but it wasn't sharp enough enough cheese or both. Simmered 15 minutes. Good soup.:)

Helpful

(42)
Rating: 3 stars
02/17/2015

I'm rating it 3 because I have to rate it. But for a suggestion since I've made the Panera copycat before. First is to blend the ingredients, minus the cheese, in a blender. Second, the secret ingredient is a pinch of nutmeg to the final product. And btw making a roux before adding the liquids gives it more depth.

Helpful

(37)

You May Like Also

  • Cooking Schoolthis link opens in a new tab
  • Ask the Communitythis link opens in a new tab
  • Cooking Schoolthis link opens in a new tab
  • Ask the Communitythis link opens in a new tab
  • Does Pumpkin Pie Need To Be Refrigerated?
  • Does Pumpkin Pie Need To Be Refrigerated?
  • 11 Apple Crumble Recipes for Celebrating Fall
  • 11 Apple Crumble Recipes for Celebrating Fall
  • See All Breakfast and Brunch Recipes
  • Our 15 Best Cinnamon Roll Recipes
  • Our 15 Best Cinnamon Roll Recipes
  • Breakfast Burrito Recipes
  • Breakfast Casserole Recipes
  • 18 Easy Lunches You Can Make in 20 Minutes or Less
  • 18 Easy Lunches You Can Make in 20 Minutes or Less
  • Sandwich Wraps and Roll-Up Recipes
  • School Lunch Ideas and Recipes
  • 17 Best Boneless Chicken Breast Recipes Ready in 30 Minutes or Less
  • 17 Best Boneless Chicken Breast Recipes Ready in 30 Minutes or Less
  • See All Appetizer & Snack Recipes
  • Our Best Thanksgiving Appetizer Recipes
  • Our Best Thanksgiving Appetizer Recipes
  • Our 10 Most Popular Thanksgiving Pies for Your Feast
  • Our 10 Most Popular Thanksgiving Pies for Your Feast
  • Baking Tips and Techniques
  • Frosting and Icing Recipes
  • Pineapple Upside-Down Cake Recipes
  • Sugar-Free Dessert Recipes
  • 9 Cranberry Cocktails for Making Spirits Bright
  • 9 Cranberry Cocktails for Making Spirits Bright
  • Cocktail Tips and Techniques
  • Our 15 Best Chicken Casseroles of All Time Are the Best Comfort Food
  • Our 15 Best Chicken Casseroles of All Time Are the Best Comfort Food
  • Macaroni and Cheese Recipes
  • 18 Pear Salad Recipes To Make the Most of Pear Season
  • 18 Pear Salad Recipes To Make the Most of Pear Season
  • See All Side Dish Recipes
  • 10 Quick and Easy Homemade Cranberry Sauces
  • 10 Quick and Easy Homemade Cranberry Sauces
  • Broccoli Side Dish Recipes
  • Vegetable Side Dish Recipes
  • See All Soup, Stew & Chili Recipes
  • Our 10 Best Potato Soups of All Time to Keep You Full and Cozy
  • Our 10 Best Potato Soups of All Time to Keep You Full and Cozy
  • Chicken and Dumpling Recipes
  • 15 Vegetarian and Vegan Recipes for a Southern Thanksgiving Feast
  • 15 Vegetarian and Vegan Recipes for a Southern Thanksgiving Feast
  • See All Diet & Healthy Recipes
  • 10 Top-Rated Diabetic-Friendly Desserts That Are Low In Sugar, But High In Flavor
  • 10 Top-Rated Diabetic-Friendly Desserts That Are Low In Sugar, But High In Flavor
  • Mediterranean Diet Recipes
  • See All Holidays & Entertaining
  • How to Plan What You're Making for Thanksgiving Dinner
  • How to Plan What You're Making for Thanksgiving Dinner
  • Recipes for Super Bowl(R)
  • St. Patrick's Day Recipes
  • 17 Polish Recipes to Make Your Grandmother Proud
  • 17 Polish Recipes to Make Your Grandmother Proud
  • 3 Ways to Safely Thaw a Frozen Turkey
  • 3 Ways to Safely Thaw a Frozen Turkey
  • Recipe Conversion and Scaling
  • Decorating Cakes, Cookies and Other Desserts
  • Grilling and Other Outdoor Cooking
  • Kitchen Tools and Techniques
  • Allrecipes Magazine Recipes
  • Food Wishes with Chef John
  • See All Food News and Trends
  • 5 Potato Chip Flavors Worth a Trip to the Asian Market Right Now
  • 5 Potato Chip Flavors Worth a Trip to the Asian Market Right Now
  • Cooking Schoolthis link opens in a new tab
  • Ask the Communitythis link opens in a new tab
  • Cooking Schoolthis link opens in a new tab
  • Ask the Communitythis link opens in a new tab
  • Soups, Stews and Chili Recipes
  • Subscribethis link opens in a new tab
  • Customer Servicethis link opens in a new tab
  • Jobsthis link opens in a new tab
  • Advertisethis link opens in a new tab
  • Appsthis link opens in a new tab
  • Sitemapthis link opens in a new tab
  • Canada this link opens in a new tab
  • Quebec this link opens in a new tab
  • Subscribe to Our Newsletter
  • Terms of Servicethis link opens in a new tab
  • Ad Choicesthis link opens in a new tab
  • California Do Not Sellthis link opens a modal window
  • Web Accessibilitythis link opens in a new tab